The Sherry Murders

Romance scams, or “lonely hearts” scams, are one of the oldest swindles in the book. They work when a fraudster gains the affection of a victim, usually in a long-distance relationship. Once the scammer establishes trust, they will request money or financial information from their victim. The advent of the internet and dating sites has made lonely hearts scams more popular and harmful than ever. Join us for today’s episode to discover how, through a complex web of lies and a brigade of greedy, immoral people, one particular lonely heart scam would end in the cold-blooded murders of Judge Vincent Sherry and his wife, Margaret Sherry.

Content Warnings: murder, police corruption, scams & manipulation


Everlywell – And for listeners of the show, Everlywell is offering a special discount of twenty percent off an at-home lab test at

True Crime Podcast Festival:
Follow my socials:

Thank you for listening – if you enjoyed this episode please leave a positive review and rating on apple podcast or your podcast player of choice, it really does help.

You can find us on most social media channels, Twitter @tcfcpod,, and Instagram @truecrimefanclubpod & of course, our website is

If you have an episode suggestion, send us an email at


This episode was researched by Haley Gray and written by Andrea Marshbank. 

Content editing by Brittney Martinez.

Produced by Neeks at WeTalkofDreams – check him out on Twitter @WeTalkofDreams or

Production assisted by Jesse Hawke

Interested in my audiobook? Download it now on Audible: The Little Demons Inside, by Micah Thomas

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *